Were They “Worse Sinners”? 9/11

[rightsonword]

Were They “Worse Sinners”?

Each year on September 11, Americans recall the horror of the 2001 terrorist attacks against the USA that occurred at the two towers of the World Trade Center in New York City and the Pentagon in Washington DC, and also the crashing of a hijacked plane in rural Pennsylvania. In addition, people all over the world will also be reminded today of these four terrible events and the loss of thousands of American lives.

For me personally, it was quite moving when I visited New York City a few years ago and made sure I paid a visit to Ground Zero. Today, two almost-complete skyscrapers and a memorial park stand there as reminders of that tragic day.1

Ground Zero

Here is how Ground Zero looked a few years ago when I visited New York City.

On this day in America, we continue to grieve with the nation eleven years after the events of 9/11. Christians in particular should reach out with compassion to the families that are still affected. After all, thousands of our relatives were killed during these terrorist attacks (you see, we are all related to each other because we are all descendants of one man, Adam).

Since 9/11, people have often asked why God would allow such a terrible tragedy that killed “so many innocent people.”

Now, while I do not in any way want to take away from the grievous nature of these horrible events and the devastating impact on so many families and friends, I wanted to take this opportunity to remind us of one of the realities of this life—that all us will die one day!

In Luke 13, Jesus gave two examples where people were killed in “tragic” events, and both times He asked the question as to whether the victims were “worse sinners” than others. We read the following:

There were present at that season some who told Him about the Galileans whose blood Pilate had mingled with their sacrifices. And Jesus answered and said to them, “Do you suppose that these Galileans were worse sinners than all other Galileans, because they suffered such things? I tell you, no; but unless you repent you will all likewise perish. Or those eighteen on whom the tower in Siloam fell and killed them, do you think that they were worse sinners than all other men who dwelt in Jerusalem? I tell you, no; but unless you repent you will all likewise perish.” (Luke 13:1–5)

Now, notice something from the passage. The answer Jesus gave was the same for both examples here in Luke 13. He said, “"I tell you, no; but unless you repent you will all likewise perish."”

Let’s put it this way. Noting that people were killed by Roman soldiers and by a falling tower, Jesus asked if they were worse sinners and that’s why they died. He answered “no” and then said to “repent.”

In a modern context, we could take this passage and apply it this way: Those people at the World Trade Center, the Pentagon, and Pennsylvania who were killed by the terrorists—were they worse sinners than others? The answer would be, “No, not at all. But you need to repent!”

Digging deeper, we need to understand that every person is a sinner.

For all have sinned and fall short of the glory of God. (Romans 3:23)

This teaching from the Apostle Paul reminds us that there are no “innocent” people, in the sense that everyone is a sinner and therefore accountable to the One we have sinned against—our Creator God. No one is without sin. The Bible makes it clear that all sinners (which means all human beings) are under God’s judgment for sin, and the penalty for sin is death.

Therefore, just as through one man sin entered the world, and death through sin, and thus death spread to all men, because all sinned. (Romans 5:12)

When Jesus spoke during His earthly ministry about those people killed by the soldiers and the falling tower, He was reminding His listeners that they were all sinners. He didn’t say, “Were they sinners?”’ but “Were they worse sinners?” He was reminding people that there is a time for everyone to die. “"A time to be born, and a time to die"” (Ecclesiastes 3:2). The Bible also makes it clear that “"it is appointed for men to die once, but after this the judgment"” (Hebrews 9:27).

Because everyone is a sinner, we will all stand before the holy God one day. But those who have been born again as the Scripture states in Romans 10:9, having confessed with their mouth the Lord Jesus and believed in their heart that God has raised Him from the dead, will be saved for eternity and live forever with their Creator in heaven.

It’s important for us to acknowledge that people perish every day. They die of old age, horrible diseases, catastrophes, and so on. There have been many terrible tragedies in recent years, such as the tsunamis that hit Japan and Indonesia, or hurricanes that devastated various places like the Gulf Coast. Of course, such tragedies are the consequences of our sin and God’s subsequent curse on the creation (Genesis 3:14–19). As Paul tells us in Romans, “"For we know that the whole creation groans and labors with birth pangs together until now"” (Romans 8:22).

As we observe this 9/11 anniversary, remember the following:

Such horrible events should remind us that everyone is a sinner, and everyone will die (unless the Lord returns first).

That we need to “"weep with those who weep"” (Romans 12:15).

That all people need to repent, and that death is a reminder of our sin and the fact that sin has separated us from our God. We will be eternally separated from God if we are not born again. What a reminder that everyone has to face death, and how important it is that all people respond to the gospel to know that they are saved for eternity.

At this time each year, we like to remind people of our free booklet dealing with the “death and suffering” issue, which can be downloaded from our website. We trust you will share this evangelistic booklet with others, so that when people think of terrible times of suffering and death, they can be reminded that they also will succumb to death one day. And yes, this booklet gives the good news of how we can be rescued from what the Bible calls the “second death,” which is eternal separation from God. We can be rescued by receiving the free gift of salvation in Jesus Christ.

I want to share with you a PDF of the booklet that I coauthored right after the tragedy of 9/11 (also available in print from our online store).

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

None of us are any less deserving of (spiritual) death than the hijackers, those who orchestrated 9/11, and those who died on that day. We have all sinned against God, none of us are good. We are destined to die and then judgment. None of us know when or how we will die, but rest assured, we each will one day: that is the only guarantee in life. God calls us all to repent because whereas the body is finite, the soul is eternal. He desires that we repent of our sins, allow Christ to take our sins upon Himself, and receive forgiveness so we can be in heaven, rather than suffer judgment in hell separated from God. Pray for those we love and more so, for those who hate us.

[Deborah Layne]

Thank you, Rightsonword.

May I point out, that when we believe that God "allows" horrible tragedies like these to happen, we are ultimately blaming Him for them? When we choose to take the "nothing happens without God's approval" road, then He is to blame for everything that satan does. Not a country on the face of the earth wouldn't execute the person responsible for this horror. Yet we implicate God for alleging that he "allowed" it to happen.

[rightsonword]

Thank you, Rightsonword.

May I point out, that when we believe that God "allows" horrible tragedies like these to happen, we are ultimately blaming Him for them? When we choose to take the "nothing happens without God's approval" road, then He is to blame for everything that satan does. Not a country on the face of the earth wouldn't execute the person responsible for this horror. Yet we implicate God for alleging that he "allowed" it to happen.

I believe God "allows" bad things to happen because we live in a sin cursed world brought by Adam's disobedience as recorded in Genesis. In the beginning, God sustained the world, the universe. It was perfect, but God has effectively taken a small step back and we are experiencing the curse: what life is like without God's entire and full presence. We pushed God away and continue to do so, each one of us through out actions and thoughts.

God offered a remedy for the situation through the blood of His son, Christ. In heaven, the lion will lay next to the lamb and they will not be enemies. Everything will be as it should have always been. It isn't so much that God allows, but that He has given us what we want: life without Him. We live with the consequences because we are responsible for our decisions. God allows it simply because He is all powerful and can control everything, if not, He wouldn't be God. He is not bound by anything we do.

In short, though God allows things to happen, we need to take comfort in that He is good and perfect and that it is difficult to comprehend His infinite ways with our finite minds. Christ had to die and God allowed Him to suffer immensely, spiritually and physically. Mary and Jesus' apostles wondered why God was allowing such a horrible thing to happen, but God had a reason. God is in control regardless if we don't understand why something happens. He is not the cause of the world's ills, we are. He simply has decided to primarily intervene when Christ returns.

But imagine a life in which God fully takes His presence away from us? We would be in hell. Life would be literal hell. God is sustaining the universe, even if there is a curse of death upon it.

[Deborah Layne]

I understand and respect your point. But I believe the Word holds up that man has dominion and authority over the Earth. God owns it; and He gave the running of it to us. This is ultimately why He had to come in the form of a human, to regain authority as a human. I believe there is massive misunderstanding regarding the sovereignty of God. He is the ultimate. He is God Almighty, and nothing and nobody can hold a candle to Him. But to implicate him in the atrocities conceived of and carried out by satan? Not a chance. He gave man choice. And He did not go back on His own word when mankind fell from grace. But to accuse Him of "allowing" people to be murdered, children to be molested, babies murdered... God does not 'allow' that. WE allow it. He has given us dominion over the earth, and he isn't an "Indian giver" Believing that God is ultimately responsible for all evil is an very bad, false doctrine than has infiltrated the Church. He is good, and all goodness and only goodness comes from Him. Satan is the thief, the killer and the one who destroys. Not God.

Thank you for sharing your faith here, and bringing attention to the Prince of Peace

[dog53]

I understand and respect your point. But I believe the Word holds up that man has dominion and authority over the Earth. God owns it; and He gave the running of it to us. This is ultimately why He had to come in the form of a human, to regain authority as a human. I believe there is massive misunderstanding regarding the sovereignty of God. He is the ultimate. He is God Almighty, and nothing and nobody can hold a candle to Him. But to implicate him in the atrocities conceived of and carried out by satan? Not a chance. He gave man choice. And He did not go back on His own word when mankind fell from grace. But to accuse Him of "allowing" people to be murdered, children to be molested, babies murdered... God does not 'allow' that. WE allow it. He has given us dominion over the earth, and he isn't an "Indian giver" Believing that God is ultimately responsible for all evil is an very bad, false doctrine than has infiltrated the Church. He is good, and all goodness and only goodness comes from Him. Satan is the thief, the killer and the one who destroys. Not God.

Thank you for sharing your faith here, and bringing attention to the Prince of Peace

+1 Deborah EVIL killed those people in that tower that awful day Not god . He lets us choose our own path in all things