I came across this article when it first posted, so I'll just post my original response from another site.
3 problems I see with this article:
1. It's a fixed exchange rate now, and not internationally traded. Central banks with fixed rates of exchange have the ability to revalue or devalue their currencies. Why would anyone pay more than the fixed market rate? So, the market argument is bogus.
2. His argument that the dealers, if they really thought it would revalue, would be hoarding dinar is ridiculous. I'm sure they've all got a nice little personal stash, but they have to make a living in the meantime, so they make money on a spread. That's the same argument we hear, all the time, about precious metal dealers. Sure, Goldline thinks gold will appreciate in the future, but it's a business, so they sell their gold at a spread, and Goldline continues as an ongoing concern.
If you think any product you sell is going to appreciate, why aren't you hoarding it, Brian Hancock, CFP?
3. Why did Forbes Magazine, a world renound financial publication, with contacts in literally every corner of the globe, have to go to little ole Birmingham, Alabama, to find some small time financial planner to call this a scam? I've lived in Birmingham my entire life, work in finance, and have never heard of Timberchase Financial. Couldn't they find someone at, say, Goldman Sachs, or the currency trading desk at JPM, or an economics professor at Princeton, or freakin' Paul Krugman, for that matter? Furthermore, why would they ask a financial planner? Those are the guys who sell insurance products and municipal bonds to old people and mutual funds to 40 hour a week employees.
My bank manager friend, who works in the ritziest part of town, tells me she's selling piles of the stuff to Birmingham's rich and famous. She's at least as good a souce as Brian Hancock.